COVERS CONTEST CONSENSUS

Tuesday, May 12, 2026

Track where expert agreement is strongest today, then use the rest of the site to decide whether the market still offers a playable edge.

This page is a decision-support board, not a blind picks feed. The highest-consensus games tell you where contest handicappers are clustering, but the strongest workflow is to compare those signals against live odds, matchup context, and the relevant betting guides before placing anything.

Open Handicapping Hub Read Sharp vs Square Money Read Closing Line Value Guide
70
Total Picks
20
Games
3
Sports
27x
Top Consensus
NHL Buffalo @ Montreal 27x TOP
27x Moneyline Buffalo ML (+105)
21x Total (Over) Over 6.0
18x Moneyline Montreal ML (-150)
13x Total (Under) Under 6.0
NHL Anaheim @ Vegas 25x TOP
25x Moneyline Anaheim ML (+115)
20x Moneyline Vegas ML (-163)
18x Total (Under) Under 6.5
16x Total (Over) Over 6.5
MLB NY Yankees @ Baltimore 22x TOP
22x Moneyline Baltimore ML (+138)
8x Total (Over) Over 8.5
5x Moneyline NY Yankees ML (-142)
3x Total (Under) Under 8.5
MLB Colorado @ Pittsburgh 21x TOP
21x Moneyline Colorado ML (+270)
9x Total (Over) Over 7.5
1x Moneyline Pittsburgh ML (-334)
1x Total (Under) Under 7.5
MLB Chi. Cubs @ Atlanta 21x TOP
21x Moneyline CHC ML (+106)
6x Total (Under) Under 9.0
6x Total (Over) Over 9.0
5x Moneyline Atlanta ML (-124)
MLB Detroit @ NY Mets 20x TOP
20x Moneyline Detroit ML (+128)
7x Total (Over) Over 7.5
5x Moneyline NY Mets ML (-148)
3x Total (Under) Under 7.5
MLB LA Angels @ Cleveland 19x TOP
19x Moneyline LA Angels ML (+116)
8x Moneyline Cleveland ML (-130)
1x Total (Under) Under 9.5
MLB Washington @ Cincinnati 19x TOP
19x Moneyline Washington ML (+122)
8x Total (Over) Over 10.0
6x Moneyline Cincinnati ML (-144)
1x Total (Under) Under 10.0
MLB St. Louis @ Athletics 19x TOP
19x Moneyline St. Louis ML (+126)
7x Total (Over) Over 10.5
6x Total (Under) Under 10.5
2x Moneyline Athletics ML (-148)
NBA Minnesota @ San Antonio 17x TOP
17x Total (Over) Over 218.5
16x Spread (ATS) Minnesota +10.5
13x Spread (ATS) San Antonio -10.5
8x Total (Under) Under 218.5
MLB Philadelphia @ Boston 17x TOP
17x Moneyline Boston ML (+124)
8x Total (Over) Over 8.5
7x Moneyline Philadelphia ML (-146)
5x Total (Under) Under 8.5
MLB Tampa Bay @ Toronto 16x TOP
16x Moneyline Toronto ML (+106)
8x Moneyline Tampa Bay ML (-124)
5x Total (Under) Under 8.0
2x Total (Over) Over 8.0
MLB San Francisco @ LA Dodgers 15x TOP
15x Moneyline San Francisco ML (+250)
2x Moneyline LA Dodgers ML (-310)
MLB Arizona @ Texas 13x TOP
13x Moneyline Arizona ML (+110)
2x Moneyline Texas ML (-130)
MLB Seattle @ Houston 13x TOP
13x Moneyline Houston ML (+142)
7x Total (Over) Over 8.5
6x Moneyline Seattle ML (-168)
5x Total (Under) Under 8.5
MLB Miami @ Minnesota 11x TOP
11x Moneyline Miami ML (-102)
10x Moneyline Minnesota ML (-116)
MLB Kansas City @ Chi. White Sox 9x TOP
9x Total (Over) Over 9.5
6x Total (Under) Under 9.5
MLB San Diego @ Milwaukee 9x TOP
9x Total (Over) Over 8.5
3x Moneyline San Diego ML (+116)
2x Total (Under) Under 8.5
NHL Minnesota @ Colorado 6x TOP
6x Moneyline Colorado ML (-213)
4x Total (Over) Over 6.5
1x Moneyline Minnesota ML (+172)
1x Total (Under) Under 6.5
NBA Cleveland @ Detroit 5x TOP
5x Spread (ATS) Detroit -3.5
5x Total (Over) Over 211.5
1x Spread (ATS) Cleveland +3.5
1x Total (Under) Under 211.5