COVERS CONTEST CONSENSUS

Monday, January 19, 2026

Top 200 picks from elite Covers.com handicappers - now grouped by game for easier viewing. Sections sorted by highest consensus.

311
Total Picks
52
Games
5
Sports
30x
Top Consensus
NHL NY Rangers @ Anaheim 30x TOP
30x Total (Over) Over 6.5
15x Moneyline NYR ML (+121)
14x Moneyline NY Rangers ML (+122)
13x Total (Under) Under 6.5
13x Moneyline Anaheim ML (-145)
10x Moneyline NYR ML (+118)
9x Moneyline ANA ML (-136)
7x Moneyline NYR ML (+117)
3x Moneyline ANA ML (-131)
NHL NY Islanders @ Vancouver 23x TOP
23x Moneyline VAN ML (+125)
16x Moneyline NY Islanders ML (-150)
14x Total (Under) Under 6.0
11x Total (Over) Over 6.0
10x Moneyline Vancouver ML (+126)
9x Total (Over) Over 5.5
8x Total (Under) Under 5.5
7x Moneyline NYI ML (-141)
4x Moneyline VAN ML (+124)
3x Moneyline NYI ML (-137)
3x Moneyline VAN ML (+126)
2x Moneyline VAN ML (+117)
NCAAF Miami @ Iu 22x TOP
22x Total (Over) Over 46.5
21x Spread (ATS) Iu -7
19x Spread (ATS) Miami +7
9x Total (Under) Under 46.5
NHL San Jose @ Florida 21x TOP
21x Total (Over) Over 6.5
15x Moneyline SJ ML (+163)
7x Total (Under) Under 6.5
4x Moneyline SJ ML (+164)
4x Moneyline SJ ML (+155)
4x Moneyline SJ ML (+168)
3x Moneyline SJ ML (+170)
3x Moneyline FLA ML (-186)
2x Moneyline SJ ML (+166)
2x Moneyline SJ ML (+152)
2x Moneyline FLA ML (-173)
NHL Philadelphia @ Veg 19x TOP
19x Moneyline Veg ML (-227)
11x Total (Over) Over 6
8x Moneyline Philadelphia ML (+185)
7x Total (Under) Under 6
NBA Miami @ Golden State 17x TOP
17x Total (Under) Under 238.5
14x Spread (ATS) Golden State -4
12x Total (Over) Over 238.5
11x Spread (ATS) Miami +4
9x Spread (ATS) MIA +5.5
7x Spread (ATS) GS -5.5
6x Spread (ATS) MIA +6.5
3x Spread (ATS) GS -6.5
NBA Boston @ Detroit 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) Boston +2
16x Spread (ATS) Detroit -2
15x Total (Over) Over 227.5
10x Spread (ATS) BOS +4.5
10x Total (Under) Under 227.5
9x Spread (ATS) BOS +3.5
7x Total (Over) Over 224.5
6x Total (Under) Under 224.5
6x Spread (ATS) DET -3.5
3x Spread (ATS) DET -4.5
2x Spread (ATS) DET -2.5
NHL New Jersey @ Calgary 16x TOP
16x Moneyline Calgary ML (+105)
15x Total (Over) Over 6.0
10x Moneyline New Jersey ML (-111)
9x Total (Under) Under 6.0
8x Moneyline CAL ML (+109)
8x Total (Over) Over 5.5
7x Moneyline NJ ML (-123)
7x Total (Under) Under 5.5
5x Moneyline CAL ML (+101)
4x Moneyline CAL ML (+112)
4x Moneyline CAL ML (+108)
4x Moneyline CAL ML (+103)
3x Moneyline NJ ML (-124)
2x Moneyline NJ ML (-112)
2x Moneyline NJ ML (-121)
NBA Indiana @ Philadelphia 15x TOP
15x Spread (ATS) Philadelphia -5
13x Total (Over) Over 227.5
11x Spread (ATS) IND +8.5
10x Spread (ATS) Indiana +5
9x Total (Under) Under 227.5
6x Total (Over) Over 228.5
6x Spread (ATS) PHI -6.5
5x Spread (ATS) IND +6.5
2x Total (Under) Under 228.5
2x Spread (ATS) PHI -8.5
NHL Minnesota @ Toronto 15x TOP
15x Moneyline Toronto ML (-111)
14x Total (Over) Over 6.0
12x Moneyline Minnesota ML (-108)
12x Total (Over) Over 6
8x Moneyline TOR ML (-123)
8x Total (Under) Under 6.0
7x Total (Under) Under 6
4x Moneyline MIN ML (+109)
4x Moneyline MIN ML (+111)
4x Moneyline TOR ML (-108)
3x Moneyline TOR ML (+100)
3x Total (Over) Over 6.5
3x Moneyline MIN ML (-110)
2x Moneyline MIN ML (+108)
2x Moneyline MIN ML (+112)
2x Moneyline MIN ML (-102)
2x Moneyline TOR ML (-126)
2x Moneyline MIN ML (+106)
2x Moneyline TOR ML (-102)
NCAAF Miami (FL) @ Indiana 15x TOP
15x Total (Over) Over 47.5
12x Spread (ATS) MIA +8.5
11x Spread (ATS) IU -8.5
5x Spread (ATS) IU -7.5
5x Total (Under) Under 47.5
4x Spread (ATS) MIA +7.5
2x Total (Over) Over 46.5
NBA Pho @ Bk 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) Pho -9
11x Spread (ATS) Bk +9
10x Total (Over) Over 215.5
8x Total (Under) Under 215.5
NHL Winnipeg @ Chicago 14x TOP
14x Total (Over) Over 6.0
10x Total (Under) Under 6.0
9x Moneyline CHI ML (+120)
6x Moneyline CHI ML (+122)
6x Moneyline CHI ML (+121)
6x Moneyline CHI ML (+119)
5x Moneyline WIN ML (-136)
3x Moneyline WIN ML (-137)
2x Moneyline WIN ML (-132)
2x Moneyline WIN ML (-135)
2x Moneyline WIN ML (-133)
NCAAB Loyola (MD) @ Lehigh 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) MD +5.5
8x Total (Over) Over 148.5
3x Total (Over) Over 147.5
3x Spread (ATS) LEH -5.5
2x Spread (ATS) MD +4.5
NHL Philadelphia @ Vegas 13x TOP
13x Moneyline PHI ML (+177)
13x Total (Over) Over 6.0
9x Total (Over) Over 6.5
9x Moneyline PHI ML (+192)
9x Moneyline VEG ML (-203)
8x Moneyline PHI ML (+191)
4x Total (Under) Under 6.0
2x Total (Under) Under 6.5
2x Moneyline VEG ML (-217)
NHL Win @ Chicago 13x TOP
13x Moneyline Win ML (-135)
13x Moneyline Chicago ML (+110)
10x Total (Over) Over 6
7x Total (Under) Under 6
NCAAB NC A&T @ Hampton 11x TOP
11x Spread (ATS) NCAT +6.5
5x Total (Over) Over 142.5
3x Spread (ATS) HAMP -6.5
NCAAB Sfa @ Nich 11x TOP
11x Spread (ATS) Sfa -4
6x Spread (ATS) Nich +4
6x Total (Over) Over 143.5
5x Total (Under) Under 143.5
NCAAB SE Louisiana @ Texas R-G Valley 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) SELA +5.5
6x Total (Over) Over 135.5
NCAAB Manhattan @ Quinnipiac 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) MAN +12.5
4x Total (Under) Under 154.5
3x Total (Over) Over 154.5
NCAAB Txso @ Jkst 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) Jkst -2
6x Spread (ATS) Txso +2
6x Total (Over) Over 156
5x Total (Under) Under 156
NCAAB Mont @ Nau 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) Mont -3
8x Total (Over) Over 144
6x Spread (ATS) Nau +3
4x Total (Under) Under 144
NCAAB LIU @ Le Moyne 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) LMC +1.5
4x Total (Under) Under 147.5
2x Total (Under) Under 146.5
2x Total (Under) Under 149.5
2x Total (Over) Over 147.5
NCAAB Cornell @ Brown 9x TOP
9x Total (Over) Over 163.5
7x Spread (ATS) COR -1.5
7x Spread (ATS) BRWN +1.5
NCAAB Princeton @ Dartmouth 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) DART -1.5
7x Total (Over) Over 145.5
6x Spread (ATS) DART +1.5
5x Total (Over) Over 144.5
5x Spread (ATS) PRIN +1.5
NCAAB Nhc @ Chs 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) Nhc +1
6x Spread (ATS) Chs -1
6x Total (Over) Over 129.5
5x Total (Under) Under 129.5
NCAAB Mtst @ Unco 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) Unco -2
7x Spread (ATS) Mtst +2
7x Total (Over) Over 152.5
5x Total (Under) Under 152.5
NCAAB Ncat @ Hamp 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) Hamp -5
6x Spread (ATS) Ncat +5
6x Total (Over) Over 143
3x Total (Under) Under 143
NFL New England @ Denver 8x TOP
8x Total (Under) Under 41.5
6x Spread (ATS) New England -5
5x Total (Over) Over 41.5
4x Spread (ATS) NE -4.5
4x Spread (ATS) DEN +4.5
3x Spread (ATS) DEN +5.5
3x Total (Over) Over 40.5
3x Spread (ATS) Denver +5
NFL L.A. Rams @ Seattle 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) SEA -2.5
5x Total (Over) Over 47.5
4x Spread (ATS) LA +2.5
3x Total (Under) Under 47.5
NBA Phoenix @ Brooklyn 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) BK +8.5
7x Spread (ATS) BK +7.5
5x Spread (ATS) PHO -8.5
3x Total (Under) Under 216.5
3x Total (Over) Over 218.5
3x Spread (ATS) PHO -7.5
3x Total (Over) Over 216.5
2x Total (Under) Under 218.5
NCAAB Bethune-Cookman @ AR-Pine Bluff 8x TOP
8x Total (Under) Under 154.5
6x Total (Under) Under 155.5
4x Spread (ATS) ARPB +2.5
3x Spread (ATS) COOK -2.5
2x Total (Over) Over 155.5
NCAAB Texas Southern @ Jackson State 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) TXSO +3.5
4x Total (Under) Under 154.5
3x Total (Under) Under 155.5
3x Spread (ATS) TXSO +2.5
2x Spread (ATS) JKST -1.5
2x Total (Under) Under 153.5
2x Spread (ATS) JKST -3.5
NCAAB Iona @ Saint Peter's 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) IONA +3.5
6x Spread (ATS) SPC -3.5
5x Total (Under) Under 142.5
2x Total (Over) Over 141.5
2x Total (Over) Over 142.5
NCAAB Montana St. @ Northern CO 8x TOP
8x Total (Over) Over 155.5
5x Total (Under) Under 155.5
5x Spread (ATS) MTST +2.5
4x Total (Under) Under 152.5
4x Spread (ATS) MTST +1.5
2x Spread (ATS) UNCO -2.5
2x Spread (ATS) UNCO -1.5
NCAAB Alabama A&M @ Alabama St. 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) ALST -1.5
5x Spread (ATS) AAMU +1.5
3x Spread (ATS) ALST +1.5
3x Total (Over) Over 144.5
2x Total (Under) Under 146.5
NCAAB Famu @ Mvsu 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) Famu -11
6x Total (Over) Over 138.5
5x Spread (ATS) Mvsu +11
4x Total (Under) Under 138.5
NCAAB Lam @ Uno 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) Lam +1
6x Total (Over) Over 146.5
5x Spread (ATS) Uno -1
4x Total (Under) Under 146.5
NCAAB Nwst @ Hbu 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) Hbu -3
6x Spread (ATS) Nwst +3
6x Total (Over) Over 139.5
4x Total (Under) Under 139.5
NCAAB Md @ Leh 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) Leh -2
7x Spread (ATS) Md +2
6x Total (Over) Over 148.5
4x Total (Under) Under 148.5
NCAAB Northwestern St. @ HCU 7x TOP
7x Spread (ATS) NWST +3.5
5x Total (Over) Over 139.5
3x Total (Under) Under 139.5
2x Spread (ATS) NWST +2.5
NCAAB Lamar @ New Orleans 7x TOP
7x Spread (ATS) LAM +1.5
4x Total (Under) Under 144.5
3x Total (Over) Over 145.5
2x Total (Under) Under 146.5
2x Total (Over) Over 144.5
NCAAB Sela @ Utrgv 7x TOP
7x Spread (ATS) Utrgv -4
6x Spread (ATS) Sela +4
5x Total (Over) Over 135.5
4x Total (Under) Under 135.5
NCAAB McNeese St. @ Texas A&M-CC 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) MCNS -8.5
5x Spread (ATS) AMCC +7.5
5x Total (Under) Under 139.5
3x Total (Under) Under 141.5
3x Spread (ATS) MCNS -7.5
NCAAB New Hampshire @ Maine 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) UNH +2.5
6x Total (Over) Over 130.5
2x Spread (ATS) ME -1.5
2x Spread (ATS) ME -2.5
NCAAB New Haven @ Chicago St. 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) NHC +1.5
5x Total (Over) Over 129.5
4x Total (Under) Under 129.5
2x Spread (ATS) CHS -1.5
NCAAB Montana @ Northern Arizona 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) NAU +4.5
3x Spread (ATS) MONT -4.5
3x Total (Over) Over 145.5
2x Total (Over) Over 144.5
2x Spread (ATS) MONT -3.5
2x Total (Under) Under 145.5
NFL Los Angeles @ Seattle 5x TOP
5x Spread (ATS) Seattle -2
3x Total (Over) Over 47.5
2x Spread (ATS) Los Angeles +2
NCAAB SFA @ Nicholls State 5x TOP
5x Total (Under) Under 144.5
5x Spread (ATS) SFA -3.5
4x Spread (ATS) SFA -1.5
4x Spread (ATS) SFA +1.5
3x Spread (ATS) NICH +1.5
2x Spread (ATS) NICH +3.5
NCAAB East Texas A&M @ Incarnate Word 5x TOP
5x Total (Over) Over 143.5
4x Spread (ATS) TAMC +8.5
2x Total (Over) Over 142.5
2x Spread (ATS) TAMC +7.5
2x Spread (ATS) TAMC +6.5
NCAAB Prairie View A&M @ Alcorn St. 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) ALCN +2.5
4x Total (Under) Under 151.5
3x Spread (ATS) PV -2.5
2x Total (Over) Over 151.5
2x Total (Over) Over 153.5
2x Spread (ATS) PV -3.5
2x Total (Under) Under 152.5
NCAAB Florida A&M @ Miss Valley St 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) MVSU +11.5
2x Total (Under) Under 140.5
2x Total (Over) Over 140.5
2x Spread (ATS) MVSU +12.5
2x Total (Under) Under 139.5
Data Source: Covers.com Contest Leaderboards (Top 200 by UNITS)
Last Updated: January 19, 2026 at 11:26 PM ET
Methodology: Picks grouped by game, sections sorted by highest consensus
← Jan 18Archive CalendarJan 20 →
Next Day →