COVERS CONTEST CONSENSUS

Friday, January 16, 2026

Top 200 picks from elite Covers.com handicappers - now grouped by game for easier viewing. Sections sorted by highest consensus.

240
Total Picks
37
Games
5
Sports
40x
Top Consensus
NHL Tampa Bay @ St. Louis 40x TOP
40x Total (Over) Over 5.5
18x Moneyline Tampa Bay ML (-200)
14x Total (Under) Under 5.5
12x Moneyline STL ML (+165)
7x Moneyline STL ML (+160)
7x Moneyline TB ML (-183)
7x Moneyline St. Louis ML (+165)
5x Moneyline TB ML (-185)
3x Moneyline STL ML (+178)
2x Moneyline STL ML (+174)
2x Moneyline STL ML (+166)
NHL San Jose @ Detroit 29x TOP
29x Total (Over) Over 6.5
20x Moneyline SJ ML (+174)
15x Moneyline Detroit ML (-155)
10x Moneyline San Jose ML (+148)
10x Total (Over) Over 6
7x Total (Under) Under 6
6x Total (Under) Under 6.5
5x Moneyline SJ ML (+175)
4x Moneyline SJ ML (+176)
3x Moneyline SJ ML (+154)
2x Moneyline SJ ML (+143)
2x Moneyline DET ML (-195)
2x Moneyline DET ML (-171)
2x Moneyline SJ ML (+152)
NFL Buffalo @ Denver 22x TOP
22x Total (Over) Over 46.5
20x Spread (ATS) Buffalo +1
17x Spread (ATS) Denver -1
15x Total (Under) Under 46.5
7x Spread (ATS) DEN +1.5
7x Spread (ATS) BUF -1.5
5x Total (Under) Under 46.0
4x Spread (ATS) BUF +1.0
3x Total (Over) Over 46.0
NHL Anaheim @ Los Angeles 22x TOP
22x Total (Over) Over 6.0
19x Moneyline ANA ML (+136)
14x Moneyline Los Angeles ML (-136)
10x Total (Under) Under 6.0
10x Moneyline Anaheim ML (+133)
8x Total (Over) Over 6
7x Total (Under) Under 6
4x Moneyline ANA ML (+140)
4x Moneyline LA ML (-151)
4x Moneyline ANA ML (+138)
3x Moneyline ANA ML (+128)
3x Moneyline ANA ML (+121)
2x Moneyline LA ML (-157)
2x Moneyline ANA ML (+127)
2x Moneyline LA ML (-159)
NBA Minnesota @ Houston 20x TOP
20x Spread (ATS) MIN +4.5
14x Spread (ATS) Minnesota +4
12x Spread (ATS) Houston -4
11x Total (Over) Over 222
9x Total (Under) Under 222.5
8x Spread (ATS) HOU -4.5
8x Total (Under) Under 222
6x Total (Over) Over 222.5
2x Total (Over) Over 221.5
NHL Florida @ Carolina 18x TOP
18x Total (Over) Over 6.0
15x Total (Under) Under 6.0
14x Moneyline Florida ML (+156)
13x Moneyline FLA ML (+142)
12x Moneyline Carolina ML (-174)
11x Moneyline FLA ML (+138)
10x Total (Over) Over 6
7x Total (Under) Under 6
5x Moneyline CAR ML (-157)
3x Moneyline FLA ML (+156)
3x Moneyline FLA ML (+140)
3x Moneyline CAR ML (-158)
2x Moneyline CAR ML (-156)
2x Moneyline FLA ML (+155)
2x Moneyline FLA ML (+152)
NFL San Francisco @ Seattle 17x TOP
17x Spread (ATS) San Francisco +7
10x Total (Over) Over 45.0
10x Spread (ATS) Seattle -7
10x Total (Over) Over 45
10x Total (Under) Under 45
9x Spread (ATS) SF +7.0
8x Spread (ATS) SEA -7.0
2x Total (Under) Under 45.0
NFL Los Angeles @ Chicago 17x TOP
17x Spread (ATS) Los Angeles -4
16x Spread (ATS) Chicago +4
13x Total (Over) Over 48.5
11x Total (Under) Under 48.5
NBA New Orleans @ Indiana 17x TOP
17x Spread (ATS) Indiana -4
15x Total (Over) Over 241.5
14x Total (Under) Under 241.5
11x Total (Under) Under 238.5
10x Spread (ATS) IND -3.5
10x Spread (ATS) New Orleans +4
7x Spread (ATS) IND -4.5
7x Spread (ATS) NO +3.5
6x Spread (ATS) NO +4.5
3x Total (Under) Under 239.5
NBA Cleveland @ Philadelphia 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) Philadelphia -2
12x Spread (ATS) Cleveland +2
10x Spread (ATS) PHI -2.5
9x Total (Over) Over 233
8x Total (Under) Under 233
7x Spread (ATS) CLE +1.5
7x Spread (ATS) CLE +2.5
4x Total (Under) Under 233.5
4x Spread (ATS) PHI -1.5
3x Total (Under) Under 232.5
2x Total (Over) Over 233.5
2x Total (Over) Over 232.5
NCAAB Creighton @ Providence 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) CREI -1.5
10x Spread (ATS) PROV +1.5
8x Total (Under) Under 162.5
8x Total (Over) Over 162.5
2x Total (Over) Over 161.5
NBA Washington @ Sacramento 15x TOP
15x Spread (ATS) Sacramento -7
12x Spread (ATS) WAS +7.5
11x Spread (ATS) SAC -7.5
10x Spread (ATS) Washington +7
9x Total (Over) Over 234
7x Total (Under) Under 234
6x Total (Under) Under 233.5
4x Total (Over) Over 233.5
NCAAB Baylor @ Kansas 15x TOP
15x Spread (ATS) BAY +7.5
7x Total (Over) Over 155.5
7x Total (Under) Under 155.5
6x Spread (ATS) KU -7.5
2x Spread (ATS) KU -6.5
NBA Chicago @ Bk 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) Chicago +1
11x Spread (ATS) Bk -1
9x Total (Over) Over 225.5
9x Total (Under) Under 225.5
NCAAB Il @ Day 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) Il +16
7x Spread (ATS) Day -16
7x Total (Over) Over 142
6x Total (Under) Under 142
NCAAB Ohio @ Ball 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) Ohio -5
8x Spread (ATS) Ball +5
8x Total (Over) Over 147.5
4x Total (Under) Under 147.5
NBA L.A. Clippers @ Toronto 13x TOP
13x Spread (ATS) Toronto -2
12x Spread (ATS) L.A. Clippers +2
12x Total (Over) Over 215
11x Spread (ATS) TOR +2.5
7x Total (Over) Over 215.5
7x Total (Under) Under 215
5x Total (Under) Under 215.5
4x Spread (ATS) LAC +1.5
4x Spread (ATS) TOR +1.5
4x Spread (ATS) LAC -2.5
4x Spread (ATS) LAC -1.5
3x Total (Under) Under 213.5
2x Total (Over) Over 213.5
NCAAB Colorado St. @ Boise St. 13x TOP
13x Spread (ATS) CSU +5.5
5x Total (Under) Under 141.5
5x Total (Over) Over 141.5
5x Total (Under) Under 138.5
5x Spread (ATS) BSU -5.5
NCAAB Marq @ Dep 13x TOP
13x Spread (ATS) Dep -3
9x Spread (ATS) Marq +3
8x Total (Over) Over 144.5
7x Total (Under) Under 144.5
NCAAB Bay @ Ku 13x TOP
13x Spread (ATS) Ku -7
10x Spread (ATS) Bay +7
7x Total (Over) Over 155.5
6x Total (Under) Under 155.5
NFL Houston @ New England 12x TOP
12x Spread (ATS) Houston +3
11x Spread (ATS) New England -3
11x Total (Over) Over 40.5
6x Total (Under) Under 40.5
NCAAB Csu @ Bsu 12x TOP
12x Spread (ATS) Csu +5
9x Spread (ATS) Bsu -5
8x Total (Over) Over 139.5
5x Total (Under) Under 139.5
NBA Chicago @ Brooklyn 11x TOP
11x Spread (ATS) CHI +1.5
7x Total (Under) Under 226.5
7x Spread (ATS) BK -1.5
5x Total (Over) Over 226.5
4x Total (Under) Under 225.5
2x Total (Over) Over 225.5
2x Total (Under) Under 224.5
2x Spread (ATS) CHI +2.5
NCAAB Marquette @ DePaul 11x TOP
11x Spread (ATS) DEP -3.5
9x Spread (ATS) MARQ +3.5
7x Total (Over) Over 144.5
6x Spread (ATS) MARQ +2.5
3x Total (Over) Over 142.5
3x Spread (ATS) DEP -2.5
3x Total (Under) Under 142.5
2x Total (Over) Over 143.5
NCAAB Loyola-Chicago @ Dayton 11x TOP
11x Total (Under) Under 142.5
10x Spread (ATS) IL +16.5
8x Spread (ATS) IL +17.5
5x Total (Over) Over 142.5
3x Spread (ATS) DAY -16.5
2x Spread (ATS) IL +18.5
NCAAF Miami (FL) @ Indiana 11x TOP
11x Total (Over) Over 47.5
10x Spread (ATS) IU -8.5
10x Spread (ATS) MIA +8.5
3x Total (Under) Under 47.5
NCAAB Tol @ Kent 10x TOP
10x Total (Over) Over 169.5
6x Total (Under) Under 169.5
NCAAF Miami @ Iu 10x TOP
10x Total (Over) Over 47.5
9x Spread (ATS) Miami +8
9x Spread (ATS) Iu -8
4x Total (Under) Under 47.5
NCAAB Toledo @ Kent St. 9x TOP
9x Spread (ATS) TOL +5.5
8x Spread (ATS) KENT -5.5
7x Total (Under) Under 169.5
6x Spread (ATS) KENT -4.5
4x Total (Under) Under 171.5
4x Spread (ATS) TOL +4.5
4x Total (Over) Over 169.5
2x Total (Over) Over 171.5
2x Total (Under) Under 170.5
NCAAB Crei @ Prov 9x TOP
9x Total (Over) Over 162
7x Total (Under) Under 162
NBA Dallas @ New York 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) New York -5
5x Total (Over) Over 227.5
4x Spread (ATS) Dallas +5
3x Total (Under) Under 227.5
NCAAB Ohio @ Ball St. 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) BALL +4.5
7x Spread (ATS) OHIO -4.5
6x Spread (ATS) BALL +5.5
4x Total (Over) Over 147.5
4x Total (Under) Under 147.5
4x Spread (ATS) OHIO -3.5
2x Total (Over) Over 145.5
NBA Milwaukee @ Atlanta 7x TOP
7x Spread (ATS) Milwaukee +4
5x Total (Over) Over 225.5
4x Spread (ATS) Atlanta -4
3x Total (Under) Under 225.5
2x Spread (ATS) MIL +5.5
NBA Boston @ Detroit 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) Boston +4
5x Spread (ATS) Detroit -4
5x Total (Over) Over 227.5
3x Total (Under) Under 227.5
NCAAB Stt @ Ndsu 5x TOP
5x Spread (ATS) Ndsu -1
2x Spread (ATS) Stt +1
NBA Orlando @ Memphis 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) Orlando -5
3x Spread (ATS) Memphis +5
3x Total (Over) Over 227.5
NFL L.A. Rams @ Chicago 2x TOP
2x Total (Under) Under 51.0
Data Source: Covers.com Contest Leaderboards (Top 200 by UNITS)
Last Updated: January 16, 2026 at 11:25 PM ET
Methodology: Picks grouped by game, sections sorted by highest consensus
← Previous Day (Jan 7) Next Day →