COVERS CONTEST CONSENSUS

Wednesday, December 31, 2025

Top 200 picks from elite Covers.com handicappers - now grouped by game for easier viewing. Sections sorted by highest consensus.

219
Total Picks
35
Games
5
Sports
60x
Top Consensus
NHL Boston @ Edmonton 60x TOP
60x Spread (ATS) BOS +165
20x Total (Under) Under 6.0
14x Total (Over) Over 6.0
12x Total (Over) Over 6.5
8x Spread (ATS) EDM -200
6x Total (Under) Under 6.5
6x Spread (ATS) EDM -184
4x Spread (ATS) EDM -196
2x Spread (ATS) BOS +155
2x Spread (ATS) BOS +162
NHL Philadelphia @ Calgary 38x TOP
38x Spread (ATS) PHI +118
38x Total (Over) Over 5.5
22x Total (Under) Under 5.5
16x Spread (ATS) PHI +115
16x Spread (ATS) CAL -145
8x Spread (ATS) CAL -142
4x Spread (ATS) CAL -140
2x Spread (ATS) CAL -135
NHL Buffalo @ Dallas 38x TOP
38x Spread (ATS) BUF +135
30x Total (Under) Under 6.0
18x Total (Over) Over 6.0
18x Spread (ATS) DAL -160
6x Spread (ATS) BUF +132
6x Spread (ATS) BUF +140
4x Spread (ATS) DAL -156
4x Spread (ATS) BUF +130
4x Spread (ATS) DAL -170
2x Spread (ATS) DAL -175
NCAAF Miami (FL) @ Ohio State 38x TOP
38x Spread (ATS) MIA +9.5
36x Spread (ATS) OSU -9.5
22x Total (Under) Under 40.5
18x Total (Under) Under 42.5
12x Total (Over) Over 40.5
4x Spread (ATS) OSU -10.0
4x Total (Over) Over 42.5
4x Spread (ATS) MIA +10.0
2x Total (Over) Over 41.5
2x Total (Under) Under 41.5
NFL Carolina @ Tampa Bay 28x TOP
28x Spread (ATS) CAR +3.0
12x Spread (ATS) TB -3.0
10x Total (Over) Over 43.5
6x Total (Over) Over 44.5
4x Total (Under) Under 43.5
2x Total (Under) Under 44.5
NHL New Jersey @ Columbus 28x TOP
28x Spread (ATS) NJ -110
28x Total (Over) Over 6.0
20x Spread (ATS) CLB -110
18x Total (Under) Under 6.0
10x Spread (ATS) NJ -105
6x Spread (ATS) NJ -106
6x Spread (ATS) CLB -122
2x Spread (ATS) CLB -113
2x Spread (ATS) NJ +102
2x Spread (ATS) CLB -115
NHL St. Louis @ Colorado 28x TOP
28x Spread (ATS) STL +280
24x Total (Under) Under 6.0
14x Spread (ATS) STL +260
8x Spread (ATS) COL -350
8x Spread (ATS) COL -325
8x Spread (ATS) COL -330
6x Total (Over) Over 6.0
NHL Winnipeg @ Detroit 26x TOP
26x Total (Over) Over 6.0
22x Total (Under) Under 6.0
20x Spread (ATS) WIN +105
14x Spread (ATS) DET -130
14x Spread (ATS) WIN -110
10x Spread (ATS) WIN +100
8x Spread (ATS) DET -111
8x Spread (ATS) WIN +110
4x Spread (ATS) DET -135
2x Spread (ATS) DET -110
2x Spread (ATS) DET -120
2x Spread (ATS) WIN -120
NBA Denver @ Toronto 24x TOP
24x Spread (ATS) DEN +6.5
16x Spread (ATS) TOR -6.5
10x Total (Over) Over 227.0
8x Total (Under) Under 229.0
8x Spread (ATS) DEN +7.0
8x Total (Over) Over 229.0
2x Spread (ATS) TOR -7.0
2x Total (Under) Under 227.0
NBA New Orleans @ Chicago 24x TOP
24x Spread (ATS) NO +1.0
20x Spread (ATS) CHI -1.0
6x Total (Over) Over 248.0
4x Total (Under) Under 245.5
4x Total (Under) Under 247.0
4x Total (Under) Under 248.5
4x Spread (ATS) NO +2.0
4x Total (Over) Over 247.0
2x Spread (ATS) CHI -2.0
2x Total (Over) Over 248.5
2x Total (Over) Over 245.5
2x Total (Over) Over 249.0
2x Total (Under) Under 246.5
NBA New York @ San Antonio 20x TOP
20x Spread (ATS) NY +1.5
18x Spread (ATS) SA -1.5
10x Total (Over) Over 236.0
6x Total (Under) Under 236.0
6x Spread (ATS) NY +2.0
6x Spread (ATS) SA -3.0
2x Total (Under) Under 237.0
2x Total (Over) Over 235.0
2x Total (Under) Under 234.5
2x Total (Over) Over 237.0
2x Spread (ATS) NY +2.5
2x Spread (ATS) NY +3.0
2x Total (Over) Over 234.5
2x Spread (ATS) SA -2.0
NCAAB Charleston So @ Gardner-Webb 18x TOP
18x Spread (ATS) CHSO -10.5
8x Spread (ATS) WEBB +10.5
6x Total (Over) Over 162.5
2x Total (Over) Over 163.5
2x Total (Under) Under 162.5
2x Total (Under) Under 163.5
NCAAB Appalachian St. @ Old Dominion 18x TOP
18x Spread (ATS) APP +2.5
8x Spread (ATS) ODU -2.5
4x Total (Over) Over 136.5
4x Total (Under) Under 137.5
2x Spread (ATS) ODU -1.5
NCAAB St. John's @ Georgetown 18x TOP
18x Spread (ATS) GTWN +9.5
8x Spread (ATS) GTWN +8.5
6x Total (Over) Over 154.5
4x Spread (ATS) SJU -8.5
4x Total (Over) Over 152.5
4x Total (Under) Under 153.5
4x Spread (ATS) SJU -7.5
4x Spread (ATS) SJU -9.5
4x Spread (ATS) GTWN +7.5
2x Total (Under) Under 154.5
2x Total (Under) Under 152.5
2x Total (Over) Over 153.5
NFL Seattle @ San Francisco 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) SF +1.5
10x Spread (ATS) SF -1.0
10x Total (Over) Over 49.0
8x Total (Under) Under 49.0
6x Total (Over) Over 49.5
6x Spread (ATS) SEA -1.5
4x Spread (ATS) SF -1.5
2x Spread (ATS) SEA -1.0
2x Spread (ATS) SEA +1.5
2x Spread (ATS) SEA +1.0
2x Total (Under) Under 49.5
NBA Washington @ Milwaukee 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) WAS +10.5
12x Total (Over) Over 232.0
6x Total (Over) Over 233.0
4x Total (Under) Under 232.0
4x Total (Under) Under 233.0
2x Total (Under) Under 232.5
2x Total (Over) Over 232.5
NBA Portland @ Oklahoma City 14x TOP
14x Total (Over) Over 232.5
14x Spread (ATS) POR +16.0
14x Total (Under) Under 232.5
4x Total (Under) Under 233.5
2x Total (Over) Over 233.5
2x Spread (ATS) OKC -16.0
NCAAB Nicholls State @ Texas R-G Valley 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) NICH +3.5
12x Total (Under) Under 145.5
10x Spread (ATS) UTRGV -3.5
6x Total (Under) Under 146.5
2x Total (Over) Over 146.5
2x Spread (ATS) UTRGV -4.5
NCAAB New Orleans @ Texas A&M-CC 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) UNO +3.5
12x Spread (ATS) AMCC -3.5
10x Total (Under) Under 144.5
6x Total (Under) Under 145.5
2x Spread (ATS) AMCC -5.5
2x Total (Over) Over 145.5
NCAAB South Dakota @ ND State 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) SDAK +11.5
8x Total (Under) Under 163.5
8x Total (Over) Over 163.5
2x Total (Under) Under 164.5
NCAAB Georgia St. @ Marshall 12x TOP
12x Total (Over) Over 152.5
8x Spread (ATS) MRSH -13.5
8x Spread (ATS) GAST +13.5
NCAAB Winthrop @ Longwood 12x TOP
12x Spread (ATS) LONG +8.5
6x Total (Under) Under 163.5
6x Total (Over) Over 163.5
4x Spread (ATS) WIN -8.5
NCAAB Radford @ USC Upstate 10x TOP
10x Total (Under) Under 160.5
10x Spread (ATS) SCUS +1.5
6x Spread (ATS) SCUS -1.5
6x Spread (ATS) RAD +1.5
4x Total (Over) Over 160.5
4x Spread (ATS) RAD -1.5
4x Total (Under) Under 159.5
NCAAB SFA @ Northwestern St. 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) NWST +8.5
8x Spread (ATS) SFA -8.5
6x Total (Over) Over 140.5
2x Total (Under) Under 141.5
2x Total (Over) Over 141.5
2x Total (Under) Under 138.5
NCAAB Kansas City @ Denver 10x TOP
10x Total (Over) Over 158.5
6x Spread (ATS) UMKC +11.5
6x Total (Over) Over 154.5
4x Spread (ATS) UMKC +10.5
4x Total (Under) Under 154.5
4x Total (Under) Under 157.5
2x Total (Under) Under 158.5
2x Spread (ATS) DEN -10.5
NCAAB Texas State @ Troy 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) TXST +8.5
6x Spread (ATS) TROY -8.5
4x Total (Under) Under 144.5
4x Total (Over) Over 143.5
2x Spread (ATS) TROY -9.5
NCAAB Drexel @ UNC Wilmington 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) DREX +12.5
4x Total (Over) Over 138.5
4x Total (Under) Under 139.5
2x Total (Over) Over 137.5
2x Spread (ATS) UNCW -12.5
2x Total (Over) Over 139.5
2x Total (Under) Under 137.5
NFL Cleveland @ Cincinnati 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) CIN -7.5
NFL Indianapolis @ Houston 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) HOU -10.0
NFL N.Y. Jets @ Buffalo 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) BUF -8.5
NFL Arizona @ L.A. Rams 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) LA -9.5
NFL Detroit @ Chicago 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) CHI -2.5
NFL Dallas @ N.Y. Giants 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) DAL -5.5
NFL Washington @ Philadelphia 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) WAS +4.0
NFL L.A. Chargers @ Denver 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) DEN -12.0
Data Source: Covers.com Contest Leaderboards (Top 200 by UNITS)
Last Updated: December 31, 2025 at 11:25 PM ET
Methodology: Picks grouped by game, sections sorted by highest consensus