COVERS CONTEST CONSENSUS

Friday, December 19, 2025

Top 200 picks from elite Covers.com handicappers - now grouped by game for easier viewing. Sections sorted by highest consensus.

287
Total Picks
54
Games
5
Sports
56x
Top Consensus
NHL New Jersey @ Utah 56x TOP
56x Spread (ATS) NJ +115
26x Total (Under) Under 5.5
26x Total (Over) Over 5.5
24x Spread (ATS) UTAH -140
6x Spread (ATS) NJ +110
NCAAF Alabama @ Oklahoma 52x TOP
52x Spread (ATS) OKLA -1.5
32x Spread (ATS) ALA +1.5
16x Total (Under) Under 40.5
12x Total (Under) Under 41.5
10x Total (Over) Over 40.5
10x Total (Over) Over 41.5
NBA San Antonio @ Atlanta 40x TOP
40x Spread (ATS) SA -2.5
18x Spread (ATS) ATL +2.5
10x Total (Over) Over 240.0
8x Spread (ATS) SA -2.0
8x Total (Over) Over 241.5
8x Spread (ATS) SA -3.0
8x Spread (ATS) ATL +3.0
8x Total (Under) Under 241.5
4x Total (Over) Over 240.5
4x Spread (ATS) ATL +2.0
4x Total (Under) Under 240.0
4x Total (Over) Over 242.0
2x Total (Under) Under 242.0
2x Total (Under) Under 241.0
NBA Chicago @ Cleveland 40x TOP
40x Spread (ATS) CHI +7.0
36x Total (Under) Under 240.5
18x Spread (ATS) CLE -7.0
16x Total (Over) Over 240.5
10x Spread (ATS) CLE -6.5
4x Spread (ATS) CHI +6.5
NHL Dallas @ Anaheim 40x TOP
40x Spread (ATS) ANA -105
20x Total (Under) Under 6.5
16x Spread (ATS) DAL -115
14x Total (Over) Over 6.5
8x Total (Under) Under 6.0
6x Spread (ATS) DAL -118
6x Total (Over) Over 6.0
6x Spread (ATS) ANA -102
NHL Carolina @ Florida 38x TOP
38x Spread (ATS) FLA +105
24x Total (Under) Under 6.0
20x Total (Over) Over 6.0
14x Spread (ATS) CAR -125
12x Spread (ATS) FLA +110
10x Spread (ATS) CAR -135
6x Spread (ATS) FLA -105
4x Spread (ATS) CAR -130
2x Total (Under) Under 5.5
2x Total (Over) Over 5.5
2x Spread (ATS) FLA +115
NHL Winnipeg @ Colorado 36x TOP
36x Spread (ATS) WIN +200
26x Total (Over) Over 6.0
24x Total (Under) Under 6.0
22x Spread (ATS) COL -250
4x Spread (ATS) WIN +185
2x Spread (ATS) COL -225
2x Spread (ATS) COL -235
NBA Miami @ Boston 34x TOP
34x Spread (ATS) MIA +6.5
28x Spread (ATS) BOS -6.5
14x Total (Under) Under 231.5
8x Total (Under) Under 233.5
6x Total (Over) Over 231.5
4x Total (Under) Under 232.5
2x Total (Over) Over 233.5
2x Total (Under) Under 233.0
2x Total (Under) Under 231.0
2x Total (Under) Under 232.0
2x Total (Over) Over 233.0
2x Total (Under) Under 234.0
NHL Vancouver @ NY Islanders 30x TOP
30x Spread (ATS) VAN +120
30x Total (Over) Over 5.5
26x Total (Under) Under 5.5
16x Spread (ATS) NYI -145
16x Spread (ATS) VAN +125
8x Spread (ATS) VAN +118
6x Spread (ATS) NYI -150
2x Spread (ATS) VAN +115
2x Total (Under) Under 6.0
2x Spread (ATS) NYI -135
NFL Green Bay @ Chicago 28x TOP
28x Total (Over) Over 46.5
24x Total (Under) Under 46.5
18x Spread (ATS) CHI +1.5
18x Spread (ATS) GB -1.0
16x Spread (ATS) CHI +1.0
12x Spread (ATS) GB -1.5
6x Total (Over) Over 45.5
6x Total (Under) Under 45.5
4x Spread (ATS) GB -2.5
4x Spread (ATS) CHI +2.5
4x Spread (ATS) CHI -1.5
2x Spread (ATS) GB +1.5
NBA Philadelphia @ New York 28x TOP
28x Total (Under) Under 229.0
22x Spread (ATS) PHI +5.0
16x Total (Over) Over 229.0
16x Spread (ATS) NY -5.0
10x Spread (ATS) PHI +4.0
8x Spread (ATS) NY -6.0
6x Spread (ATS) PHI +6.0
6x Spread (ATS) NY -4.0
2x Spread (ATS) PHI +3.5
NCAAB Eastern Michigan @ Akron 24x TOP
24x Spread (ATS) EMU +16.5
12x Spread (ATS) AKR -16.5
6x Total (Under) Under 158.0
NFL Philadelphia @ Washington 20x TOP
20x Spread (ATS) PHI -5.5
20x Spread (ATS) PHI -6.5
18x Total (Over) Over 44.5
16x Spread (ATS) WAS +6.5
16x Total (Under) Under 44.5
12x Spread (ATS) WAS +5.5
10x Total (Under) Under 45.5
8x Total (Over) Over 45.5
6x Total (Under) Under 45.0
4x Spread (ATS) WAS +6.0
2x Spread (ATS) PHI -6.0
2x Total (Over) Over 45.0
2x Spread (ATS) PHI -7.0
NBA Oklahoma City @ Minnesota 20x TOP
20x Spread (ATS) OKC -7.5
20x Spread (ATS) OKC -8.0
18x Spread (ATS) MIN +8.0
16x Spread (ATS) MIN +7.5
12x Total (Over) Over 231.5
8x Total (Under) Under 231.5
8x Total (Over) Over 231.0
6x Total (Over) Over 226.0
4x Total (Under) Under 231.0
4x Total (Over) Over 227.5
2x Spread (ATS) MIN +8.5
2x Spread (ATS) OKC -8.5
2x Total (Under) Under 229.0
NCAAB Dartmouth @ Sacred Heart 16x TOP
16x Total (Under) Under 155.5
12x Spread (ATS) SHU +1.0
10x Total (Under) Under 156.5
4x Total (Under) Under 156.0
4x Total (Over) Over 155.5
4x Spread (ATS) DART -1.0
2x Total (Under) Under 153.0
2x Total (Over) Over 156.0
2x Total (Under) Under 154.5
2x Total (Over) Over 156.5
NCAAF Memphis @ NC State 16x TOP
16x Spread (ATS) NCST -3.5
6x Spread (ATS) MEM +3.5
2x Total (Over) Over 57.5
NCAAB SD State @ Milwaukee 14x TOP
14x Total (Under) Under 152.5
14x Spread (ATS) SDST +1.0
6x Spread (ATS) MILW -1.0
4x Total (Over) Over 152.5
2x Total (Under) Under 149.5
2x Spread (ATS) SDST -1.0
NCAAB San Diego @ UC San Diego 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) UCSD -13.5
2x Spread (ATS) USD +13.5
2x Total (Under) Under 157.0
NCAAB ACU @ Brigham Young 14x TOP
14x Spread (ATS) AC +33.0
10x Total (Under) Under 145.5
6x Total (Over) Over 145.5
6x Spread (ATS) BYU -33.0
2x Total (Over) Over 144.5
2x Spread (ATS) BYU -34.5
2x Spread (ATS) AC +33.5
NCAAB Cal Poly SLO @ UCLA 14x TOP
14x Total (Over) Over 160.5
12x Spread (ATS) UCLA -25.5
6x Spread (ATS) CP +24.5
4x Spread (ATS) CP +25.5
4x Total (Over) Over 161.5
2x Total (Under) Under 160.5
NCAAB Washington @ Seattle 12x TOP
12x Spread (ATS) SEA +9.0
2x Spread (ATS) WASH -9.0
NCAAB Tulsa @ Western Kentucky 12x TOP
12x Spread (ATS) TLSA -2.5
10x Spread (ATS) TLSA -2.0
4x Total (Under) Under 158.5
4x Spread (ATS) WKU +2.5
4x Spread (ATS) WKU +2.0
4x Total (Over) Over 158.5
NCAAB Seton Hall @ Providence 12x TOP
12x Total (Over) Over 153.0
8x Spread (ATS) HALL +2.5
6x Total (Under) Under 153.5
6x Spread (ATS) HALL +1.0
4x Spread (ATS) HALL +1.5
4x Total (Over) Over 153.5
2x Spread (ATS) PROV -1.0
2x Spread (ATS) PROV -1.5
2x Spread (ATS) PROV -2.5
2x Total (Under) Under 153.0
NCAAB Villanova @ Wisconsin 10x TOP
10x Total (Over) Over 150.5
10x Spread (ATS) VILL +5.5
10x Spread (ATS) VILL +5.0
10x Spread (ATS) WIS -5.5
4x Spread (ATS) WIS -5.0
4x Total (Under) Under 150.5
NCAAB Belmont @ UC Irvine 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) BEL +1.0
4x Total (Over) Over 149.5
4x Spread (ATS) UCI -1.0
2x Total (Under) Under 149.5
NCAAB Mount St. Mary's @ Drexel 10x TOP
10x Spread (ATS) DREX -5.0
8x Spread (ATS) MSM +5.0
4x Spread (ATS) DREX -4.5
2x Spread (ATS) MSM +4.5
2x Total (Over) Over 140.5
NFL New England @ Baltimore 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) BAL -3.0
2x Spread (ATS) NE +3.0
NCAAB Miss Valley St @ Florida State 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) FSU -41.5
6x Total (Over) Over 160.5
4x Spread (ATS) MVSU +41.5
4x Spread (ATS) FSU -39.5
4x Spread (ATS) FSU -40.0
2x Total (Over) Over 158.0
2x Spread (ATS) MVSU +40.5
2x Spread (ATS) MVSU +39.5
NCAAB Coppin St. @ Navy 8x TOP
8x Total (Under) Under 141.5
4x Total (Under) Under 142.5
2x Spread (ATS) NAVY -20.5
2x Spread (ATS) COPP +20.5
2x Total (Over) Over 142.5
NCAAB Florida A&M @ Tarleton State 8x TOP
8x Total (Under) Under 150.0
4x Total (Over) Over 150.0
2x Total (Over) Over 145.5
NCAAB Morgan St. @ California 8x TOP
8x Spread (ATS) CAL -27.0
6x Spread (ATS) MORG +27.0
6x Total (Under) Under 152.0
2x Spread (ATS) MORG +26.5
2x Total (Under) Under 151.5
NFL Tampa Bay @ Carolina 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) CAR +3.0
NCAAB Norfolk State @ Jackson State 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) JKST +5.5
4x Total (Under) Under 139.5
4x Spread (ATS) NORF -5.5
2x Total (Over) Over 134.5
2x Total (Over) Over 137.5
2x Spread (ATS) JKST +6.5
2x Total (Over) Over 139.5
NCAAB Florida Atlantic @ Saint Mary's 6x TOP
6x Total (Over) Over 143.5
4x Total (Under) Under 143.0
4x Total (Under) Under 143.5
4x Total (Over) Over 143.0
2x Spread (ATS) FAU +13.5
NCAAF Washington State @ Utah State 6x TOP
6x Spread (ATS) USU -3.0
NFL Pittsburgh @ Detroit 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) DET -7.0
NFL Buffalo @ Cleveland 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) BUF -10.0
2x Spread (ATS) CLE +10.5
2x Total (Under) Under 41.5
NFL L.A. Chargers @ Dallas 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) DAL -2.0
NCAAB Hampton @ Grambling State 4x TOP
4x Total (Over) Over 137.5
4x Spread (ATS) HAMP -2.0
4x Spread (ATS) GRAM +2.0
2x Total (Under) Under 137.5
NCAAB Alcorn St. @ Baylor 4x TOP
4x Total (Under) Under 163.5
4x Total (Under) Under 162.0
4x Total (Over) Over 162.5
2x Spread (ATS) ALCN +34.5
2x Spread (ATS) BAY -34.5
2x Total (Over) Over 163.5
2x Total (Over) Over 162.0
NCAAB SE Louisiana @ Louisiana State 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) SELA +23.5
4x Total (Under) Under 144.0
4x Total (Over) Over 144.0
2x Spread (ATS) LSU -24.5
NCAAB North Alabama @ Loyola Marymount 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) UNA +10.0
2x Total (Under) Under 140.0
2x Spread (ATS) UNA +11.5
2x Spread (ATS) UNA +10.5
2x Spread (ATS) UNA +11.0
2x Spread (ATS) LMU -10.0
2x Spread (ATS) LMU -11.0
2x Spread (ATS) LMU -10.5
NCAAF Miami (FL) @ Texas A&M 4x TOP
4x Spread (ATS) MIA +3.5
2x Total (Over) Over 51.5
NFL N.Y. Jets @ New Orleans 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) NO -4.5
2x Spread (ATS) NYJ +5.0
2x Total (Under) Under 40.5
2x Total (Under) Under 40.0
NFL Kansas City @ Tennessee 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) TEN +3.0
NFL Minnesota @ N.Y. Giants 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) MIN -3.0
2x Spread (ATS) NYG +3.0
2x Total (Under) Under 43.5
NFL Cincinnati @ Miami 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) MIA +4.5
2x Spread (ATS) CIN -4.5
2x Spread (ATS) CIN -2.5
NFL Atlanta @ Arizona 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) ATL -2.5
2x Total (Under) Under 48.0
NFL Jacksonville @ Denver 2x TOP
2x Total (Under) Under 47.0
2x Spread (ATS) JAC +3.0
2x Total (Over) Over 45.5
NFL Las Vegas @ Houston 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) LV +14.0
2x Total (Under) Under 38.0
NFL Denver @ Kansas City 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) DEN -6.0
NFL San Francisco @ Indianapolis 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) SF -6.0
NCAAF James Madison @ Oregon 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) JMU +21.5
2x Spread (ATS) ORE -21.5
NCAAF LSU @ Houston 2x TOP
2x Spread (ATS) HOU -3.0
Data Source: Covers.com Contest Leaderboards (Top 200 by UNITS)
Last Updated: December 19, 2025 at 04:50 PM ET
Methodology: Picks grouped by game, sections sorted by highest consensus

Previous Days

Dec 19 (Current) Dec 18 Dec 17 Dec 16 Dec 15